Asked and answered many times, but I can't get it working!!!

(On CentOS) I have the user userA and I want to remove it from group sftponly.

#groups userA
userA : sftponly
#id -Gn userA
#gpasswd -d userA sftponly
Removing user userA from group sftponly
gpasswd: unknown member userA

#tail /etc/group
#tail /etc/passwd

so gpasswd not working. Also:

usermod -G fourpoints fourpoints 

No result.

I don't know really what to do, I'm not sure about editing /etc/group either...


Ran into the same issue. Was able to do the following to resolve this:

gpasswd -d user group

  • 3
    No idea why this answer has not been upvoted. It's best practice! – Valentin Bajrami May 21 '15 at 20:25
  • 1
    As pointed out by @glasnhost, this does not work if the group you want to remove, is the users main group; on Centos 7 anyways. Switching the main group first, then running gpasswd no longer gives me errors like gpasswd: user 'userA' is not a member of 'sftponly' – PanPipes Jan 25 '18 at 10:48

You cannot remove this user from that group given it's the only group that they're a member of. This is evident in the output being returned to you by the groups userA command:

$ groups userA
userA : sftponly

Also the id output:

$ id -Gn userA

Look in the /etc/passwd file for this user, this is most probably their primary group. You'll have to either move them to another group (by changing their primary in /etc/passwd) or delete their account entirely.


I think it's necessary first to change the main group to the userA:

#usermod -g userA userA

and then the user can be removed from the group with gpasswd

  • 1
    This answer, plus @chris-olin allowed me to remove a user from a group that was their current default, without getting errors like: gpasswd: user 'userA' is not a member of 'sftponly'. This was on Centos 7. – PanPipes Jan 25 '18 at 10:51

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.