1

[Ubuntu 16.04.7, Jailkit]

I'm having a strange issue whereby chroot <rootJailFolder> issues a warning groups: cannot find name for group ID xxx but the group ID xxx foes not exist in the file system of the jail. The problem doesn't seem to affect anything in the jail.

I was able to make the warning go away by adding the group to the local etc/group file, but clearly this isn't the optimal solution.

I don't know why I'm getting the warning, and am wondering if anyone else has experienced this issue before and have a fix for it?

0

If I recall correctly, that message indicates the jailed user (as it exists in the main /etc/passwd//etc/group files outside the jail) is a member of a group that has no name defined for it within the jail.

The effect within the jail is that any processes will not be able to refer to that group by name and will usually show the GID number instead.

This might confuse users that are unfamiliar with this behavior, for example they might confuse the GID number with the file size in a "ls - l" listing. But if you can live with that, you can ignore it - it is essentially just a warning.

If the group membership is unnecessary, you should remove it or replace it with a dummy group created for the jailed user (as it's a basic requirement that a user must be a member of at least one group, to allow that group to be used as the group owner of any files created by the user).

If the group is necessary but you don't want to disclose its real name to processes within the jail, you can certainly use a non-descriptive dummy name for that GID in the local etc/group file within the jail. All the filesystem functions will go by the GID numbers anyway; the name is for humans only.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.