1

I have a simple Linux disk image that is made with syslinux and I want to boot it from a USB key. I originally partitioned the image with parted, so it has a partition table and the first partition is marked as bootable.

I dd'd the image to a USB key, and it will boot on a PC I have (call it computer A) but it won't boot another PC (computer B) that I need to use. So I know the image is legit.

If I take the same USB key, use unetbootin and make a bootable key with a Fedora ISO, it will boot on Computer B... So Computer B definitely supports booting from USB keys.

Here's the difference though: With the Fedora image, the USB key shows up as a hard disk (USB-HDD0) in the boot menu but with my custom disk image it shows up as a removable drive (USB-ZIP0).

What controls whether a USB key shows up as a hard disk or as a removable drive?

Update:
As per K7AAY's request I made a gparted live usb, ran

echo "0 0 0" > /sys/class/scsi_host/host0/scan

and there is no output. I tried host0 thru host4, no output. I don't know what that command is supposed to do.

  • As noted in unix.stackexchange.com/questions/4561/… it is highly platform dependent. Can you generate a second LiveUSB and see if there a change on Computer B when you run echo "0 0 0" >/sys/class/scsi_host/host/scan? Please paste the result into your question after clicking edit. Please do not click on Add Comment as new comments can shove old comments off screen; your information about your PC and installation should all go in the Question so we can all see your findings. – K7AAY Jul 8 at 20:23
0

This isn't an answer to the question but a workaround.

I got my custom linux build to boot on Computer B with a usb key by first making a FAT32 partition on the usb key using GParted, and marked the partition as bootable. Then I used dd to get a disk image from the usb key. Then I put the mbr on it, used syslinux on it and now it boots on computer B.

Gparted makes it a partition of type B (win95) and parted makes it type C (win95 lba). I tried using fdisk to change the partition made with parted to be type B, but it still doesn't work.

So there's something else that determines this whole thing. I would still like to know the answer. When googling this issue, it seems that bootable usb's has been a perennial problem.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.