I want the script to open a file and read the file line by line then count the number of commas per row/line. If that is more than the $2 parameter value, then write the offending line number (from my read loop) and the total commas found to a log file.

I'm not sure what's wrong, but I'm getting a no parent error.

filename=$1 #First input parameter path with filename
pipe=$2  #Total Pipe Value

#Filename to parse
if [ $filename -ne $1 ]
   echo "Filename required"
   exit 1

#Check pipe/comma
if [ $pipe -ne $2 ]
   echo "Filename and number of expected pipes required"
   exit 1
if [ -f $1 ]
while read -r line
echo Line#"$i:" "${#count}" pipe per line compare to "$2" expected
done <$filename
if [ $count > $2 ]
echo Line# "$i" has "${#count}" pipe in total > uhs_sm_qa_csv.ksh.log
exit 0

Output of script:

[root@uhspaastream01 scripts]# ksh uhs_sm_qa_csv.ksh test.txt 10
uhs_sm_qa_csv.ksh[6]: [: test.txt: no parent
Line#1: 1 pipe per line compare to 10 expected
Line#2: 1 pipe per line compare to 10 expected
Line#3: 1 pipe per line compare to 10 expected
Line#4: 1 pipe per line compare to 10 expected
Line#5: 1 pipe per line compare to 10 expected

Contents of test.txt:


Contents of the log fileuhs_sm_qa_csv.ksh.log:

Line#5 has 1 pipe in total
  • 1
    If you're expecting two parameters to the script, you should probably test that "$#" -eq 2 before assigning or using the parameters. – Jeff Schaller Mar 16 '18 at 19:58
  • 1
    This looks like a very roundabout way to count / act on the number of separators per line: it would be far simpler IMHO to use awk or perl and use the number of fields minus 1 e.g. awk -F'|' 'NF>n+1 {printf("Line# %d has %d pipe in total\n",NR,NF-1)}' n=2 filename – steeldriver Mar 16 '18 at 20:04
  • @steeldriver Hmmm how would I implement that into my script? – fball4life36 Mar 18 '18 at 3:37

While I find it odd that you're comparing a variable to something that you just set it to, the core issue is that you're using a numeric comparison operator (-ne) for what's expected to be a filename (of text). Instead, use:

if [ "$filename" != "$1" ]

... where I've also quoted your variables.

Bonus points to steeldriver's comment, which prompted me to look a little further into this.

Based on my testing, I believe that ksh sees the ne numeric comparison operator and is performing a round of variable & arithmetic expansion on the two operands $filename and $1. As such, $filename turns into test.txt, which ksh recognizes as a possible compound variable. Since test is unset, you receive the error test.txt: no parent.

  • 1
    Presumably the specific error [: test.txt: no parent is because (in the context of the -ne numeric test) test.txt is being interpreted as a ksh93 compound variable ? – steeldriver Mar 17 '18 at 13:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.