From https://unix.stackexchange.com/a/94200/674

If there are no positional parameters ($# is 0), then "$@" expands to nothing (not an empty string, but a list with 0 elements)

So how differently do an empty string and a list with 0 elements behave?

Does "a list with 0 elements" mean "an array with 0 elements"? I don't see bash has the concept of list.

Can "nothing" mean something which is not necessarily a "list" or array?


Yes, most shells do not have a concept of a list (for variables).
That is not a defined type of content (separate from string or number).

However, the parameters of a command are a list.

That is a very special kind of data type, one that only "$*" or "$@" would express as a list. But with differences:

$ set -- one two t33
$ printf '<%s> ' "$*" ; echo
<one two t33>

$ printf '<%s> ' "$@" ; echo
<one> <two> <t33>

$ for s; do printf '<%s>' "$s" ; done; echo

Having explained that, what the quote means is that a list of parameters with 0 elements is equivalent to a list with no elements.

  • In short: the list disappears (there are no elements to print):

    $ set -- 
    $ echo $#
    $ printf '<%s>' "$@" ; echo
    $ for s in "$*"; do echo "<a>" ; done
    $ for s in "$@"; do echo "<a>" ; done

The last code prints "nothing", not even an "empty" (null) string.

So, about your question:

Can "nothing" mean something which is not necessarily a "list" or array?

No, "nothing" is necessarily a (empty) "list". However, a "null string" is something.


Basically, $# gives you number of parameters. 0 is also a number, which indicates no parameters were gives. $@ however, expands to nothing, which means you can't evalute it. (e.g check if there were any parameters at all). Try it yourself in a script, and see how it behaves.

When you want to check how many parameters were provided, for example your script counts that 3 required parameters are provided - you would $#.

When you need to actually do something with the parameters, you would use $@.

See some examples from TLDP internal variables

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.