1

I am running a command as such:

submit -n 72 -x '--mail-type=END -N2'

This command works. However, when I set it as an alias:

alias foo='submit -n 72 -x '--mail-type=END -N2''

it fails with the error:

bash: alias: -N2: not found

However, this alias works just fine:

alias foo='submit -n 72 -x '-N2''

So there is something specifically about the --mail-type=END snippet that causes problems.

EDIT: Changed alias='... to alias foo='...

  • In short: quotes don't nest. The second ' ends the quoting, so there's an unquoted space between the END and -N2. The final two quotes quote an empty string, which gets concatenated to the -N2, so they don't do anything. – ilkkachu Apr 19 '17 at 21:54
  • That's not a valid alias declaration. Do you actually have something like alias foo='submit -n 72 -x '--mail-type=END -N2'' or are you in actual fact attempting to assign this string to a variable named alias? – tripleee Apr 20 '17 at 3:45
  • Yes, I realize now that I typed it wrong in the post but in real life it's alias foo='submit -n 72 -x '-N2'' – captainalright Apr 20 '17 at 16:15
3

The quoting is off. Instead try using "" to contain '' (though "" interpolates $variables, which you may or may not want)

alias="submit -n 72 -x '--mail-type=END -N2'"

Or use the '\'' trick to "end the current single quote, insert a literal quote, restart the current single quote". That is, any inner ' is replaced with '\''

alias='submit -n 72 -x '\''--mail-type=END -N2'\'''

Here's how I verified whether the quoting produced a single unbroken string and not two words like yours does:

# not ok, two distinct words
$ perl -E 'say for @ARGV' 'submit -n 72 -x '--mail-type=END -N2''
submit -n 72 -x --mail-type=END
-N2

# ok, a single string
$ perl -E 'say for @ARGV' 'submit -n 72 -x '-N2''                
submit -n 72 -x -N2
$ 

# ok, single quotes within doubles
$ perl -E 'say for @ARGV' "submit -n 72 -x '--mail-type=END -N2'"
submit -n 72 -x '--mail-type=END -N2'

# ok, '\'' trick
$ perl -E 'say for @ARGV' 'submit -n 72 -x '\''--mail-type=END -N2'\'''
submit -n 72 -x '--mail-type=END -N2'
$ 

As for foo='submit -n 72 -x '-N2'', that is not nested; quotes on unix do not nest, this is why shells have $(cmd ... $(cmd ...)) instead of trying to figure out how to nest that using only backticks. foo='submit -n 72 -x '-N2'' is a more verbose and complicated way to say foo='submit -n 72 -x '-N2 or even more simply foo='submit -n 72 -x -N2'.

  • This works! But I don't understand why alias foo='submit -n 72 -x '-N2'' works also as I mentioned? It also has nested single quotes. – captainalright Apr 20 '17 at 16:16
  • They are not actually nested, they are adjacent. submit -n 72 -x (space) is quoted, and followed by an unquoted N2, which is followed by a quoted empty string. – tripleee Apr 20 '17 at 16:25
1

You cannot nest quotes. A simple workaround is to use different quotes:

alias foo='submit -n 72 -x "--mail-type=END -N2"'

A much better workaround is to not use an alias. Use a function instead.

foo () {
    submit -n 72 -x '--mail-type=END -N2' "$@"
}

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.