5

The command

$ wget -r http://www.comp.brad.ac.uk/research/GIP/tutorials/index.html

only downloads index.html and robots.txt for me, even though there are links in it to further pages in the same directory. For example

<A HREF="viewp.html">Viewpoint specification</A>

Why does wget ignore that?

11

it's generally a mistake in tech to mistake ones own fundamental ignorance for a flaw with the technology one is completely ignorant of.

I tested this, and found the issue immediately:

wget respects robots.txt unless explicitly told not to.

wget -r http://www.comp.brad.ac.uk/research/GIP/tutorials/index.html
--2015-12-31 12:29:52--  http://www.comp.brad.ac.uk/research/GIP/tutorials/index.html
Resolving www.comp.brad.ac.uk (www.comp.brad.ac.uk)... 143.53.133.30
Connecting to www.comp.brad.ac.uk (www.comp.brad.ac.uk)|143.53.133.30|:80... connected.
HTTP request sent, awaiting response... 200 OK
Length: 878 [text/html]
Saving to: ‘www.comp.brad.ac.uk/research/GIP/tutorials/index.html’

www.comp.brad.ac.uk/research/GI 100%[======================================================>]     878  --.-KB/s   in 0s     

2015-12-31 12:29:53 (31.9 MB/s) - ‘www.comp.brad.ac.uk/research/GIP/tutorials/index.html’ saved [878/878]

Loading robots.txt; please ignore errors.
--2015-12-31 12:29:53--  http://www.comp.brad.ac.uk/robots.txt
Reusing existing connection to www.comp.brad.ac.uk:80.
HTTP request sent, awaiting response... 200 OK
Length: 26 [text/plain]
Saving to: ‘www.comp.brad.ac.uk/robots.txt’

www.comp.brad.ac.uk/robots.txt  100%[======================================================>]      26  --.-KB/s   in 0s     

2015-12-31 12:29:53 (1.02 MB/s) - ‘www.comp.brad.ac.uk/robots.txt’ saved [26/26]

FINISHED --2015-12-31 12:29:53--

As you can see, wget did what it was asked by you, perfectly.

What does the robots.txt say in this case?

cat robots.txt
User-agent: *
Disallow: /

So this site doesn't want robots downloading stuff, at least not ones that are reading and following the robots.txt, usually this means they don't want to be indexed in search engines.

wget -r -erobots=off  http://www.comp.brad.ac.uk/research/GIP/tutorials/index.html

Now, if wget is simply too powerful for you to learn, that's fine too, but don't make the error of thinking the flaw is in wget.

There's a risk to doing recursive downloads of a site however, so it's sometimes best to use limits to avoid grabbing the entire site:

wget -r -erobots=off -l2 -np  http://www.comp.brad.ac.uk/research/GIP/tutorials/index.html
  • -l2 means 2 levels max. -l means: level.
  • -np means don't go UP in the tree, just in, from the start page. -np means: no parent.

It just depends on the target page, sometimes you want to specify exactly what to get and not get, for example, in this case, you are only getting the default of .html/.htm extensions, not graphics, pdfs, music/video extensions. The -A option lets you add extension types to grab.

By the way, I checked and my wget, version 1.17, is from 2015. Not sure what version you are using. Python by the way I think was also created in the 90s, so by your reasoning, python is also junk from the 90s.

I admit the wget --help is quite intense and feature rich, as is the wget man page, so it's understandable why someone would want to not read it, but there are tons of online tutorials that tell you how do most common wget actions.

  • 1
    Yes it is a flaw, if I say recursive, then it should do just that! Otherwise it is misdocumented! Btw I knew the levels, but it was clear that this has few. I am not a robot. – foobar Dec 31 '15 at 20:46
  • There is a reason we have (user) interfaces (and documentation) for software. Division of labour! One cannot learn every little technical detail! man wget says "Turn on recursive retrieving." and not "Turn on recursive retrieving but stop if robots.txt recommends so." I want to be in charge of my software not some webmaster, who clearly failed with his robots.txt. – foobar Dec 31 '15 at 20:54
  • Happy new year! – foobar Dec 31 '15 at 20:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.