3

Suppose we have three hosts:

  • miki - my computer behind a NAT
  • vps0 - my VPS
  • mum - computer of my mother, behind a different NAT.

The task is to connect from my computer to my mum and keep X11 forwarding. Until now I used reverse tunneling like below:

# on mum's computer (at crontab on reboot):
autossh -fN -M 3986 -R 1993:localhost:22 login@vps0

# when I want to connect to mum's computer
miki$ ssh login@vps0
vps0$ ssh localhost -p 1993

Presented above approach, has a disadvantage that I can't use X11 forwarding (-X parameter) - I can't open windows remotely.

I am wondering if is it possible to connect directly to my mum's computer and keep X11 forwarding.

PS. I sow answers in topic: SSH tunnel through middleman server - how to connect in one step (using key pair)?. Unfortunately using that solutions causes that X11 forwarding doesn't work.

4

Why doesn't that solution with ProxyCommand work for X11 forwarding? I think you can directly reach mum's computer with X11 forwarding using the following configuration.

Host mum
ProxyCommand ssh -q -W localhost:1993 login@vps0
ForwardX11 yes
2

If you understand what is going on in X11 forwarding, you will know that it is not so simple as described in the answer from @yaegashi. X11 forwarding is creating another layer under the ssh and it can't be chained as normal terminal data streams. But you are able to do it using port forwarding:

Based on this blog post, which does it as hardcoding in shell script. I was trying to do the same using ssh_config, but without any success. You just need to add complexity of the reverse tunnel the the original script

sshx () {
    # create the tunnel from vps0 to your host
    sudo ssh -Nn vps0 -L 3991:vps0:1993 &
    sleep 1s
    PID=$!
    # connect to localhost on forwrded port
    ssh localhost -XYC -p3991
    sudo kill $PID
}

I hope it will work for you

  • 1
    I believe it's so simple as described in my answer in this case. – yaegashi Aug 18 '15 at 17:11
  • have you tried? – Jakuje Aug 18 '15 at 17:17
  • 1
    Yup. I regularly use multi-hop ssh with ProxyCommand and ForwardX11 to connect remote hosts behind router and invoke X11 apps there. Simple chain of ssh -X should also work, OP can do ssh -X login@vps0 followed by ssh -X localhost -p 1993 and have correct $DISPLAY on mum's computer. – yaegashi Aug 18 '15 at 17:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.