4

I don't quite understand this behaviour of bash test operator. I used this line to determine if vagrant is installed.

if [ $(vagrant --version > /dev/null) ]; then echo "HELLO"; fi

I now know that this returns false (1) and that you should type only

if vagrant --version > /dev/null; then echo "HELLO"; fi

to get the expected result. But I still don't understand why [ $(vagrant --version > /dev/null) ] returns false (1). Shouldn't it return true (0) since

$(vagrant --version > /dev/null)

returns true, which is an expression (isn't it?).

From test man page:

The test utility evaluates the expression and, if it evaluates to true, returns a zero (true) exit status; otherwise it returns 1 (false). If there is no expression, test also returns 1 (false).

  • 1
    $(vagrant --version > /dev/null) produce no output in case of success. test with empty string return false as defined by POSIX. – cuonglm Aug 7 '15 at 17:55
  • $(vagrant --version > /dev/null) is not an expression, it is simply a subcommand. Test expressions are: File type and characteristic tests, access permission tests, string tests, or numeric tests, and connectives !, -a, and -o. Test doesn't return the status of an internal command, it returns a status depending on the evaluation of an expression. – Mike S Aug 7 '15 at 18:05
  • BTW, you probably want if vagrant --version > /dev/null 2>&1; then echo "HELLO"; fi – Mike S Aug 7 '15 at 18:06
3

All these are equivalent:

[ $(vagrant --version > /dev/null) ]
[]
test

shells are not like other programming languages. They have 2 outputs: The return value, and stdout. You are passing stdout to test, but stdout is the empty string, as it has been redirected.

What you were looking for is.

[ $(vagrant --version > /dev/null; echo $? ) ]

However [ 0 ] and [ 1 ] etc all return true because [ … ] with a single word inside tests if the word is non-empty. So you need

[ $(vagrant --version > /dev/null; echo $? ) = 0 ]

or more simply

vagrant --version > /dev/null

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.