I have an array whose elements may contain spaces:

set ASD "a" "b c" "d"

How can I convert this array to a single string of comma-separated values?

# what I want:
"a,b c,d"

So far the closest I could get was converting the array to a string and then replacing all the spaces. The problem is that this only works if the array elements don't contain spaces themselves

(echo $ARR | tr ' ' ',')

2 Answers 2


Since fish 2.3.0 you can use the string builtin:

string join ',' $ASD

The rest of this answer applies to older versions of fish.

One option is to use variable catenation:

echo -s ,$ASD

This adds an extra comma to the beginning. If you want to remove it, you can use cut:

echo -s ,$ASD | cut -b 2-

For completeness, you can also put it after and use sed:

echo -s $ASD, | sed 's/,$//'
  • Those cut/sed approaches only work if the elements of the array don't contain newline characters. tail -c +2 would be more appropriate. Feb 5, 2018 at 15:29

You can use printf and paste instead of echo and tr:

printf '%s\n' $ASD | paste -sd,

AFAIK, fish has no builtin way for joining array elements.

  • 1
    not sure if it was added in the interim or before but the command to join array elements is string join [(-q | --quiet)] SEP [STRING...] - example: string join \n $PATH
    – tbjgolden
    Dec 12, 2020 at 23:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.