2

Summary findings:

  1. I'm using get-iplayer v2.82. The files I produce on hard drive are all mp4.

  2. I've discovered the following (downloading same TV program in both cases): Using --modes=flashstd and --tvmode=flashhigh2 gives a watchable quality file which is the same filesize as the qualities above this that --modes and --tvmode can deliver.

    The VERY NEXT step down in quality from the above settings (from my experimenting) is
    --modes=flashstd and --tvmode=flashstd1. This gives a smaller filesize, but is NOT a watchable quality.

    The point being that you don't seem to be able to drop down from a "too big" filesize to a smaller size and retain watchable quality.

  3. My command line had the following form:
    get-iplayer --get 1234 --modes=flashstd --tvmode=flashhigh2

    I tried:

    i) --modes=flashstd --tvmode=flashhigh2

    Result: Filesize 170Mb (too big for my liking).
    (TV program: "The Slammer" from BBC iplayer, 30 minute duration, watchable quality.)

    ii) --modes=flashstd --tvmode=flashstd1

    Result: Filesize 110Mb (an acceptable size, but NOT watchable quality).
    (TV program: Same program as above, from BBC iplayer, 30 minute duration, NOT watchable quality (some murky pixelation)).

    iii) For comparison: TV program: "Terry and June", from YOUTUBE, mp4, only 90Mb filesize (ACCEPTABLE), 30 minutes duration, WATCHABLE QUALITY.


Full Details:

  1. My aim is to avoid downloading files with get-iplayer that are twice as big as similar-duration programs that I download from youtube. You see I don't want to swallow up disc space.

  2. I've deduced the following:

    --modes:
    Specifies the recording quality you want (in your file on the hard drive). For example, if you had a video tape recorder, then LP (long play) recording mode is a lower recording quality than SP (standard play).

    --tvmode:
    Specifies the quality of TV program that you want to fetch from the BBC end (eg., HD, SD, and the sub-qualities within these).

  3. I've intelligently experimented with combinations of --modes and --tvmode, but at the point at which a smaller file is produced, its quality isn't good enough to watch.

  4. When I download say a 30 minute TV program from youtube, the filesize is say 90Mb (mp4), and of watchable quality. But with get-iplayer (downloading from BBC), for the same program duration of 30 minutes, I can't produce a file that is less than about 170Mb AND that is of watchable quality.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.