I know Debian is general purpose, so a Debian install could just as easily be a server as a desktop. It seems, however, that even with a DVD of disk1 from Debian, it is downloading a tremendous number of files from the network mirror. I would have thought a DVD would be enough to get a base desktop installation running. What am I missing here?

Let me clarify: I chose "SSH Server" and "Desktop Environment" in tasksel. Is GNOME not a part of the primary installation DVD?

  • Can you give some examples? What package sets or packages did you ask for? Perhaps it's just downloading updates rather than packages? – Mikel Apr 26 '11 at 3:59

Because the full debian distribution for even a single architecture now well exceeds seven DVDs, and the packages on each DVD are sorted by popularity, not by common theme.

Every single installation manual strongly recommends installing from a minimal CD or USB image (100 MB or less, generally) and installing over the internet, or a local apt proxy if you have multiple systems to set up.

In addition to that, the DVDs do not contain the latest versions of all packages -- security updates aren't automatically integrated into the DVD images until the next point release. Regenerating the entire image set (Remember there's roughly seven DVDs per architecture for a dozen or so actively supported architectures and you'll see why the development team prefers not to do live rebuilds every single time a package is updated.)

| improve this answer | |

You would get better response if

  • you didn't use such a vague and inflammatory title (I've fixed that for you);
  • you gave a list of packages you chose to install, and a list of packages that were not on the DVD.

Your question being what it is, here are two guesses:

  • The packages downloaded from the network are security or other updates, issued after the DVD image was built.
  • You have unusual tastes.

As mentioned in the Debian CD FAQ, packages are sorted into Debian CDs and DVDs mainly according to their popularity.

| improve this answer | |
  • I don't see what was so inflammatory about the initial title. – tshepang Apr 26 '11 at 0:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.