13

Increasingly I am dissatisfied by the fact, that configuring my linux desktop usually means removing bloat instead of adding and tweaking features. I have come to the conclusion that I would rather begin with something very minimal and then add packages I learn about that provide additional functionality.

So I am looking for either a very minimal desktop distribution or even better a tool to build such a distribution. Or in other words I want to replace the package manager with a pre-runtime build tool.

A package manager won't hurt but I am looking for a distribution that focuses on advanced upfront configuration instead of a huge package repository

I have looked at various minimal desktop distributions but they all appear to solve different problems, e.g. are designed to run on older hardware or run from cd/stick/ramfs. But I don't want a minimal distribution because my I have old hardware but because I want to know what purpose the various parts play. Running from main memory doesn't help there either, I want something minimal and simple.

Since it appears there are no distributions that are designed for the kind of minimalism I have in mind an obvious choice would be to build Linux From Scratch. However while I want the build process to be highly customization it also has to be automated because I will have to run it quite a few times until I have a system I am satisfied with.

While a tool for lfs exists that can automate the build process it's not really integral part. Basically it extracts the steps required to build the system from the documentation and then does it automatically. I am looking for something a little more robust and advanced and also don't feel like editing xml.

After a bit of searching I found Buildroot which is intended to build embedded distributions but also allows the installation of X11. Before building a toolchain and then a rootfs the build can be configured using make menuconfig just like Linux. This looks exacly like what I had in mind, except that it is intended for cross compiling for embedded systems.

What I currently have in mind is using buildroot but first ripping out all the embedded specific part replacing them with the respective parts from lfs. Lot's of work.

Also there are some problems with buildroot most importantly (as it appears from my limiting testing) just enabling an additional package results in the hole thing being rebuild from scratch, but for trivial changes I would like to avoid that.

Before I make that time investment I will continue my search for a desktop distribution with a pre-installation build tool like buildroot, are an alternative to/fork of buildroot intended for building desktop distributions.

Edit: The answers so far point me to distributions like e.g. Gentoo, which is what I am currently using. But I am looking for an alternative to distributions like Gentoo, Arch, Debian etc. as these distributions are not minimal enough. Also one has to customize these distributions after installation. I want something that can be customized before installation.

While all of the mentioned distributions are fine distribution they are not what I am looking for. What I am looking for is "buildroot for desktop". If you do not know what buildroot is then you probably won't be able to provide an answer which satisfies me.

Also I don't think that this question is subjective. I simply can not find anything that comes close to my needs and am therefor asking you to point me to projects that might provide at least parts of what I need.

|improve this question
4

You could use something like Kickstart, which is a feature of the anaconda installer of Fedora, CentOS, RHEL, and derived distributions that lets you completely customize an installation to your liking. You can choose which packages you want to install, the partition layout, network configuration, package repositories, root password, and much more. You can also create pre and post-installation scripts that do whatever else you might want. You can run the install fully automated, or pick and choose what you'd like it to prompt for. All settings are defined in one simple (not XML) text file, which you can make by hand or with the graphical system-config-kickstart tool.

Once you've got that put together, you can roll your own custom CD if you like, or set a network location in your kickstart file, which can be a local or Internet mirror, via FTP, HTTP, or NFS. Your kickstart file can also be on the network, so you can just burn one stub install disc to bootstrap the installation (or use vanilla install media) and have it use as many different configurations as you can stand. You can even network boot it, eliminating removable media altogether.

The network options or custom spun media eliminate you from needing the "huge package repository", yet it will still be there if you decide you want to add something. But, if you want to go whole hog, you can build your own repository, cherry-picking RPMS from upstream, customizing SRPMS to your liking, rolling your own, or even hacking a make && make install or tar -jxf into the post-install script.

Many distributions have similar functionality, some of which also understand Kickstart files even if they don't implement their entire feature set (like Debian).

|improve this answer
  • Thanks for the pointer to kickstart. I only had a quick look at it's documentation so I don't know yet if it will serve my needs but it certainly looks interesting. You understood what I am looking for, congratulations :-) I won't "accept" your answer yet, because I still want to encourage more answers. I am still looking for a builder originating from a minimalist distribution rather than from a mainstream one. The latter might get it right too but I still have a little more faith in the former. Thanks again. – tarsius Apr 19 '11 at 10:03
1

Well, if you think Gentoo's emerge been pulling too many dependencies, you could try Slackware. Or one of its derivatives. Out-of-the-box, Slackware doesn't try to resolve dependencies. At all.

You might also want to explore Lunar Linux, or CRUX.

|improve this answer
  • It's not that I have never heard of these distributions before rather I have ruled them out in the past. However I will reconsider; from a fresh look they seem at least worth doing that. Thanks. – tarsius Apr 19 '11 at 10:06
1

I know this is kinda late in the game to reply but have you tried using http://susestudio.com/ ? You can choose all the packages you like to make it as small as you want without the bloat. You can make your own repository. You can upload your own packages to be available inside your repo. It will take you a couple hours to get it the way you want but it will save you the trouble of buildroot.

|improve this answer
1

Did you come across LFScript as well?

Linux From Script (or 'LFScript') is an unofficial alternative for 'Automated Linux From Scratch'. LFScript includes thoroughly tested scripts generated from the LFS and BLFS books, with which you can build a complete Linux operating system from scratch.

Some further barebones Linux distros (to check out via wikipedia) inlcude:

  • Tiny Core Linux
  • Salix OS
  • SliTaz and Tiny SliTaz
  • Damn Small Linux
  • ...
|improve this answer
0

Gentoo Linux lets you build exactly what you want. From practically nothing to a full-bloat desktop. It is basically a build system that also lets you customize build-time features.

|improve this answer
  • I have been using Gentoo for many years now. I have also used catalyst, metro and recently my own build script to build my own customized stages before installation. When I still had some multimedia apps installed there were around 700 packages installed, now after removing those I am down to ~400. And that after removing many useflags bringing in useless dependencies and removing some packages that while useful came with to many dependencies. Not minimal. – tarsius Apr 14 '11 at 10:51
  • So, do you also expect to do anything useful with it? ;-) – Keith Apr 14 '11 at 12:47
  • 1
    I would rather invest time in installing things that are still missing instead of investigating what something which is already installed does only to learn that I do not needed it but nevertheless cannot remove it because it is hardwired into the distribution. – tarsius Apr 14 '11 at 13:34
0

There are lots of options for this actually, and this will get into the realm of Subjective.

I personally use PLD-Linux, which allows me to build a working linux system in about a dozen commands (format the file system, mount it, install a package set, configure the boot loader, set a hostname, etc). When it comes to packages, I can pick one package that I need and my system comes out with just the dependencies for that app. If I need apache, I install that, and the system comes up with nothing but the basics need to make that run. If I need firefox, I install that and get a basic set of X dependencies and basically nothing else. I have a couple script to automate this further to just one or two commands to make a working virtual system with a specific purpose.

Several other linux distros like ArchLinux, and Gentoo specialize in being either lightweight or tailored to your needs. If you want more specific help with one of them....

|improve this answer

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.