Take the 2-minute tour ×
Unix & Linux Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for users of Linux, FreeBSD and other Un*x-like operating systems.. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I read about setting up ssh keys in Linux and have some questions. Correct me if I'm wrong…

Let's say host tr-lgto wants to connect to host tr-mdm using ssh. If we want to be sure that it's the real tr-mdm, we generate a pair of keys on tr-mdm and we add the public key to known_hosts on tr-lgto. If tr-mdm wants to check that it's the real tr-lgto, then tr-lgto has to generate a keypair and add the public key to authorized_keys on tr-mdm.

Question 1: There is no user field in file known_hosts, just IP addresses and hostnames. tr-mdm might have a lot of users, each with their own .ssh folder. Should we add the public key to each of the known_hosts files?

Question 2: I found that ssh-keyscan -t rsa tr-mdm will return the public key of tr-mdm. How do I know what user this key belongs to? Moreover, the public key in /root/.ssh/ is different from what that command returns. How can this be?

share|improve this question
add comment

2 Answers 2

You're mixing up the authentication of the server machine to the client machine, and the authentication of the user to the server machine.

Server authentication

One of the first things that happens when the SSH connection is being established is that the server sends its public key to the client, and proves (thanks to public-key cryptography) to the client that it knows the associated private key. This authenticates the server: if this part of the protocol is successful, the client that the server is who it pretends it is.

The client may check that the server is a known one, and not some rogue server trying to pass off as the right one. SSH provides only a simple mechanism to verify the server's legitimacy: it remembers servers you've already connected to, in the ~/.ssh/known_hosts file on the client machine (there's also a system-wide file /etc/ssh/known_hosts). The first time you connect to a server, you need to check by some other means that the public key presented by the server is really the public key of the server you wanted to connect to. If you have the public key of the server you're about to connect to, you can add it to ~/.ssh/known_hosts on the client manually.

Authenticating the server has to be done before you send any confidential data to it. In particular, if the user authentication involves a password, the password must not be sent to an unauthenticated server.

User authentication

The server only lets a remote user log in if that user can prove that they have the right to access that account. Depending on the server's configuration and the user's choice, the user may present one of several forms of credentials (the list below is not exhaustive).

  • The user may present the password for the account that he is trying to log into; the server then verifies that the password is correct.
  • The user may present a public key and prove that he possesses the private key associated with that public key. This is exactly the same method that is used to authenticate the server, but now the user is trying to prove its identity and the server is verifying it. The login attempt is accepted if the user proves that he knows the private key and the public key is in the account's authorization list (~/.ssh/authorized_keys on the server).
  • Another type of method involves delegating part of the work of authenticating the user to the client machine. This happens in controlled environments such as enterprises, when many machines share the same accounts. The server authenticates the client machine by the same mechanism that is used the other way round, then relies on the client to authenticate the user.
share|improve this answer
add comment

My friends gave me the answer. By default key identificate machine and not user. So the keys are stored in /etc/ssh/. That's why I got different key from the one stored in /root/.ssh

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.